Is It Better to Set Penny Free in Hogwarts Legacy?
There are several options available to players in the magical realm of Hogwarts Legacy, and these decisions will influence how they go. Players must choose between freeing Penny, a house elf confined to the business, and asking her to stay and assist in running it during the "Minding Your Own Business" quest. Players are debating whether or not this seemingly straightforward choice actually affects how the game develops.
The Effects of Penny's Release
Players must choose whether to free Penny from captivity after finishing the "Minding Your Own Business" quest. Although it seems like the morally just choice to free her, gamers might be surprised to realize that it has minimal effect on gameplay. Penny will stay at the shop and help the player operate it whether they want her to stay or decide to free her. The only real distinction is that with her freedom comes slightly different cutscenes since she can wear the floppy straw hat she gets from Fastidio's dungeon.
Choice Is a Myth in Hogwarts Legacy
The "Minding Your Own Business" quest draws attention to the illusion of choice, which is a larger problem in Hogwarts Legacy. Many of the game's choices have little bearing on the plot or gameplay as a whole, despite the fact that there are many of them. Players who want for a more profound feeling of moral agency and consequence may find this unsatisfactory. In the Harry Potter universe, even using Unforgivable Curses, a choice that has a lot of weight, only causes mild negative reactions from other characters.
The Value of Moral Decisions
The decision to set Penny free has moral significance despite the lack of severe repercussions. House elves are frequently regarded as slaves in the wizarding realm, devoid of freedom and free will. Regardless of how it affects gameplay, Penny's release is a step toward identifying and eliminating this oppressive system. Setting Penny free is in line with the moral compass of gamers who want to develop a "good" character.
Absence of a Moral Framework
The impression of meaningless decisions in Hogwarts Legacy is exacerbated by the game's weak morality system. A more intricate system that monitored player choices and their effects on the environment would have added to the game's complexity and made it possible for players to more thoroughly experience the repercussions of their decisions. It's challenging for players to fully immerse themselves in the setting and craft a unique story based on their decisions because of the game's constrained morality.
The Final Judgment
The choice to set Penny free in Hogwarts Legacy ultimately boils down to personal taste. Though the choice itself doesn't really affect gameplay, it does give one an opportunity to voice their moral opinions about the wellbeing of house elves. Freeing Penny is the more fulfilling choice for gamers who enjoy roleplaying and acting in accordance with their character's moral compass. The choice might not be as important to people who place more value on the gameplay experience than on moral considerations.
It is noteworthy that this absence of noteworthy outcomes is not exclusive to the "Minding Your Own Business" quest. It's indicative of a larger pattern in the game where a lot of choices, even ones that could have severe consequences, don't really change the world or the story.
