Why Was Dr. Julian Bashir a Liability in the Dominion War Instead Of Helping The Federation Win The War?
With his augmented intellect, one would expect Dr. Julian Bashir to have used his knowledge to defeat the Dominion, but in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine's "Statistical Probabilities," Bashir supports his fellow Augments – Jack, Lauren, Patrick, and Sarina – in the conclusions of their analysis: The Federation will lose the war.
It seems as though Bashir is willing to simply accept their pessimistic findings instead of using his mind to think of solutions: Dr. Bashir believes – from his position as a doctor – that there is a 900 billion life loss if the Federation surrenders to the Dominion: Despite this finding, his character remains hopeful for the outcome. In this particular moment, Bashir is simply acting on those conclusions as he chooses not to seek a more positive outlook for the Federation in this particular moment, it was surprising for viewers. The biggest cast of characters from all of those Trek series, they will be essential for the Dominion War, and yet, it seems like Dr. Bashir chose not to contribute as his own role – in a much larger scheme.
Did Star Trek: DS9 Lose The Dominion War Due To Dr. Bashir's Negative Attitude?
Star Trek: DS9 won the war - against the Dominion, as the Federation and its allies (including the Klingons and the Romulans) would later join forces with the Federation. There were a number of reasons why they were successful in defeating those forces that posed a serious threat to the galaxy, and yet it seemed like Dr. Bashir, was not one of the characters who made a big difference to the war's outcome.
Captain Benjamin Sisko was a pivotal character in helping to win this war - he made several strategic choices and, alliances which helped make the war less daunting. But, throughout the Dominion War - and while he continued to be pessimistic – he was constantly bemoaning the potential outcomes: Despite his feelings - he was willing to continue his role as Chief Medical Officer and remain as a member of that team, to be an asset.
Does Dr. Bashir Ever Help To Win Star Trek: DS9's Dominion War?
While Dr. Bashir might not have been a significant force - in a traditional sense, he was a key member of those important characters - he would go on to make those key contributions: From the perspective of a doctor. He played a vital role in treating both those crew members who fought on the front lines, and those individuals who were often the first to encounter new, challenging, medical cases. This meant that Dr. Bashir, in many ways – he was one of the most influential characters as he had the power to make a critical impact on the outcomes of this series – this is where Dr. Bashir, as a doctor would shine.
In a major conflict - and especially in a war - it seems that Dr. Bashir was more focused on those situations that were going to require his medical expertise and those medical events which would demand that Dr. Bashir bring his skills to the table.
Were Augments Used To Win The War Against The Dominion In Star Trek: DS9?
The Dominion were one of the most powerful threats to face the Federation - with a very distinctive strategy - which would often lead to very tragic outcomes. This involved, of course, a strategy which used very advanced technology. Those who have watched Star Trek: DS9 might also be aware of those characters and, those moments where they were confronted with very dangerous and complex, scientific scenarios.
While those augment characters (Dr. Bashir and, those other key Augments - who were introduced to audiences) they were all a force to be reckoned with, and would help contribute: But it was their minds - and their abilities to understand science. Augments played a vital role in helping the Federation find ways to survive - and even potentially find a path to victory - it would be a critical outcome as they attempted to understand those scientific secrets.
But, while those events would take place throughout this series - it wasn’t always a success. Augments often played an important part, but often it seems as though there were obstacles, and those tragic outcomes that could occur. The story - it was not all about the war effort - but about a series that explored a different kind of war and those series - that is focused on the internal conflict that could be faced, particularly those moments when someone who has been trained to do one thing, needs to make choices which are much harder than they appear.
How Did The Dominion's War Impact Dr. Julian Bashir's Life?
The Dominion war had an impact on Dr. Bashir’s character development as it forced him to confront, to reconcile with his identity and those issues that he would have to deal with. As the series progressed, we learned that Bashir had a unique past, he would face challenges as he attempted to come to terms with his past and reconcile it.
Those events also showed that Bashir would eventually find a way to deal with the pressures and demands of this particular conflict: From a humanitarian perspective – as a doctor - his focus remained to save lives: As viewers learned just how he could face his past and yet he was able to come to a point where he would face those challenges with a fresh outlook.
How Did Dr. Bashir React To The Discovery Of His Augmentation In Star Trek: DS9?
Dr. Julian Bashir had always lived his life, with the understanding that he was an average, normal person: Those who were raised in the Federation might not have been aware of this particular issue. The Federation, from its beginnings was established on those key principles: that all citizens, who lived in the Federation - and, who were seeking those things - peace - a just and fair society.
As Bashir was confronted with the realization – he would find a way to cope. In a moment where Bashir was forced to make a key decision: It was one that would have far-reaching consequences and he was a member of this world who was committed to a society that had, of course – faced a lot of internal struggles.
