Simpsons Thanksgiving Episodes: Ranked From Best to Worst

Gobble 'Til You Wobble! every Simpsons Thanksgiving episode, Ranked!

The Simpsons' Surprisingly Sparse Thanksgiving Feasts

The Simpsons have been gracing our screens since 1989, giving us 30+ years of hilarious antics. Yet, despite all that time, Thanksgiving specials are surprisingly rare! The show has a boatload of Christmas specials (17!) and "Treehouse of Horror" Halloween episodes (34!), but only a handful of Thanksgiving episodes exist; making many people scratch their heads in confusion; and creating a sense of urgency to review this surprisingly lesser-known content. Considering Thanksgiving is a major American holiday and the Simpsons are arguably a beloved national treasure; the scarcity is pretty astonishing, and many have attempted to unravel exactly why these were released. To understand this, we should first appreciate its general popularity which also affects how many would look at this surprising amount. This lack of quantity, along with general production challenges faced by The Simpsons; resulted in that generally mixed bag of episodes; with this show generating wildly differing views on certain released titles and the quality across several titles greatly varies, too.

The Simpsons have even created 7 Thanksgiving episodes– including ones with Christmas or Halloween elements! The show’s known for skewering just about anything; the relative few Thanksgiving episodes really stand out! We are going to cover each of the very specific Thanksgiving specials ever made by this extremely famous and prolific show; and to understand its lasting impact, and explain how some of its elements completely defined how many came to perceive The Simpsons’ creative approaches, those general stylistic aspects; especially that comedic approach and the impact this show had on society in general; providing sharp social commentaries alongside intensely memorable plots!

Also Read: The Simpsons Treehouse of Horror 2024: Halloween Spooktacular!

Every Simpsons Thanksgiving Episode: A Deliciously Uneven Spread

Here's a breakdown of every Thanksgiving-themed episode—a mixed bag of quality ranging from utter brilliance to... well, let’s be nice and call those some unfortunate instances and examples that don't truly encapsulate what The Simpsons represents and its usually incredibly higher standards for those kinds of writing!

"Bart vs. Thanksgiving"
"Homer vs. Dignity"
"Homer the Moe"
"Holidays of Future Passed"
"Thanksgiving of Horror"
"Poetic Interlude" ("Treehouse of Horror XXXII")
"Stepbrother From the Same Planet"

Also Read: The Simpsons Season 36: Could This Premiere Finally Solve The Biggest Mystery?

Ranking the Turkey Day Triumphs (and Turkeys!)

7. "Bart vs. Thanksgiving" (Season 2, Episode 7): A Nostalgic Classic

This early episode shows some amazingly well-made family conflict between Bart and Lisa surrounding Thanksgiving; It showcases how early-season Simpsons focused more on those familial relationships; resulting in more relatable scenarios for viewers. Even if those kinds of zany comedic moments were far less prevalent– it remains an important showcase of what really makes The Simpsons work; resulting in this relatively simpler storyline compared to other seasons and with slower-paced jokes emphasizing these key sentiments that ended the episodes– emphasizing emotional impacts instead of jokes alone. There’s a bittersweet family reunion after Bart's mischief.

6. "Homer vs. Dignity" (Season 12, Episode 5): A Thanksgiving Disaster

Bart and Lisa Simpson fighting at Thanksgiving in The Simpsons Image

Widely considered one of The Simpsons' WORST episodes, this outing’s incredibly grim. Homer becomes Burns’ “prank monkey,” resulting in violence far beyond normal Simpsons standards. The only Thanksgiving element? Homer's role as Santa; thus showing it is nothing but just filler in a nonsensical episode filled with crude jokes, showcasing an example where some questionable themes from the show have appeared.

5. "Homer the Moe" (Season 13, Episode 3): Moe’s Madcap Makeover

Mr. Burns next to Homer dressed as Santa in a parade in The Simpsons Image

Totally different from "Bart vs. Thanksgiving," this one has tons of fast-paced jokes. It's crazy: Moe redesigns his bar after this really odd mentoring episode, and Homer opens a hunting lodge, just to get Duff for his friends. That’s insane! While there’s very little Thanksgiving in the plot; those quirky moments where Moe's friends come together show the “chosen family” aspect which highlights a uniquely important social element often appearing in this show’s storytelling, further showcasing its emotional depth.

4. "Holidays of Future Passed" (Season 23, Episode 9): A Heartwarming Look Ahead

Homer Simpson in the alley behind Moe's in The Simpsons Image

This Simpsons episode cleverly combines Thanksgiving and Christmas. It depicts how some people in this timeline celebrate this. Yet it doesn’t stop there. This features those sweet scenes about Homer, Lisa and their eventual children appreciating their family, becoming extremely memorable and widely beloved by Simpsons fans. Some viewers believe it deserved being the series finale for The Simpsons; because of how well that ending fits the overall thematic development! Its heartwarming approach shows another unique approach. It has another interesting detail; it’s incredibly well-liked; demonstrating those rare moments when it balances both emotional impact and comedic relief in exceptional manners!

3. "Thanksgiving of Horror" (Season 31, Episode 8): A Unique Approach

Simpsons Thanksgiving of Horror banner. Image

This insanely ambitious episode totally blends Thanksgiving and Treehouse of Horror! Those three spooky stories center on the holiday which is extremely unusual, yet totally unique to The Simpsons! This unique concept really creates this insanely long episode; yet those varied scenes which are clearly parodies of widely popular culture in television– demonstrates just how unique its thematic choices become. That clever nod to Black Mirror and those cranberry sauce jokes—all those moments show just how unique this experiment really was, although only receiving a single Emmy nomination.

2. "Poetic Interlude" ("Treehouse of Horror XXXII"): A Darkly Delightful Interlude

Bart Simpson in a Thanksgiving episode on Halloween. Image

This one has the insane element–this was featured in Treehouse of Horror, which featured five unique and unrelated stories. The overall quality was still extremely strong and it becomes one of its most impressive episodes because of how those multiple and very disparate approaches all remain connected and still produce those unique experiences; that one interlude showing this Edward Gorey homage (Vincent Price narration, a Thanksgiving story arc) showcasing another innovative direction showing how the show makes even those very small details surprisingly strong and unique!

1. "Stepbrother From the Same Planet" (Season 34, Episode 8): A Hilariously Familiar Plot!

MV5BYjFkMTlkYWUtZWFhNy00M2FmLThiOTYtYTRiYjVlZWYxNmJkXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyNTAyODkwOQ@@._V1_ Image

That Thanksgiving episode involves a classic Simpsons element– that new step-brother for Homer! This is all setup through Grampa's new girlfriend's son, thus adding this new unexpected element of sibling rivalry into this show. Yet this plots repeats storylines (a near copy of "Brother From Another Planet")! This kind of storyline is both unique yet incredibly memorable because it uses existing familiarity and plot patterns, showcasing another excellent, surprising direction that continues to entertain; although, this somewhat questionable reuse is something many critics had noted as possibly negative.

Also Read: Will Bart Simpson Finally Age Up In The Simpsons? Fans Are Worried!

Conclusion: The Simpsons’ Thanksgiving Episodes Remain Enduringly Memorable

Despite its relative scarcity; Those Thanksgiving episodes for The Simpsons shows a great diversity; ranging from truly hilarious storylines to deeply emotionally charged episodes; some extremely popular and fondly remembered (like "Bart vs. Thanksgiving"), to those controversial, wildly divisive, problematic outliers like "Homer vs. Dignity". These are however a reminder, folks; the series has maintained its capacity to produce excellent storytelling across so many seasons; this quality, along with its cultural impacts truly sets The Simpsons apart.