Raymond assumed innocent theory: Killer
One of the most intriguing hypotheses about the Apple TV+ series "Presumed Innocent" holds that Raymond, an apparently moral and likeable character, might be Carolyn Polhemus's actual killer. Though first shocking, this theory provides a convincing justification for several apparently unconnected story points and character motivations.
Why might Raymond be the killer?
Bill Camp's Raymond has been shown from the beginning as a faithful friend to Rusty Sabich and a loving husband. He seems to have unshakable integrity, hence he is an unusual suspect. Still, this apparently perfect front could be a deft red herring.
Raymond's Access to Sensitive Data
According to the theory, Raymond's awareness of the specifics of Carolyn's murder—especially the way she was discovered tied up—pointes to his involvement. Raymond had access to private information about the Bunny Davis murder case as the state attorney handling it. Given the murder of Carolyn reflects some features of the Bunny Davis case, this access qualifies him as a possible suspect.
Unusual Behavior and Questionable Statements
Raymond's actions all through the show generate more questions. His unexpected fall in episode 6, apparently driven by case-related anxiety, points to a more intense involvement. In the early episodes, Raymond also constantly exhorts Rusty not to take other suspects into account, almost as if he's trying to steer the inquiry away from himself.
Raymond's Desperate Power Demand
The theory also implies that Carolyn's murder may have been motivated by Raymond's quest of dominance. His merciless quest of power is shown by his response to learning about Rusty's affair with Carolyn: he blames him for his election loss instead of expressing compassion. This need for control may have driven him to kill Carolyn, so endangering his political career.
Carolyn's Bunny Davis Case Knowledge
Raymond's behavior might have started with Carolyn's knowledge of the second DNA sample discovered at the Bunny Davis crime scene, which clears Reynolds. Should Carolyn have intended to share this disclosure with others, Raymond's political aspirations would have been compromised and his reputation would have suffered. Raymond might have been pushed to quiet her in order to save his career.
How This Theory Diffiates from the Original Source Material?
Although the TV show draws mostly on Scott Turow's book and the 1990 film adaptation, showing Raymond as the killer would greatly deviate from the source material. Raymond briefly had an affair with Carolyn in both the book and the film, but he is not ultimately involved in her murder. Rather, Rusty's wife Barbara is the guilty party.
Is Raymond the Killer?
As the show runs on, the ultimate question is whether Raymond is really accountable for Carolyn's death. Though it's still up for debate, the theory offers a convincing framework for comprehending his behavior and goals. The writers of the show have left the mystery open-ended so that viewers stay interested right until the last disclosure.
