Black Bird: True Crime Series Review - Apple TV+

Black Bird: Separating Fact From Fiction in Apple TV+'s Gripping true crime Drama

Black Bird: The Unbelievable True Story Behind Apple TV+'s Hit Series

Apple TV+'s Black Bird is a wild ride—a true crime thriller following Jimmy Keene (Taron Egerton), a disgraced ex-footballer, who makes a deal with the FBI: befriend convicted serial killer Larry Hall (Paul Walter Hauser) in prison, get a confession, and get his freedom. It sounds insane, right? But it’s all based on a truly unbelievable real-life story told in Jimmy Keene and journalist Hillel Levin's memoir, In with the Devil. And it’s way more twisted than you think.

Black Bird accurately depicts much of the reality of this unique encounter and those elements involved! The show features all real people– including Larry’s twin brother Gary (Jake McLaughlin), FBI agent Brian Miller (Greg Kinnear), and Ray Liotta's final role as Jimmy's father. However, even this remarkably close-to-reality production couldn’t replicate those events and those moments perfectly, with details missing and omitted and that even this perfectly realized storyline might have even had those gaps.

Also Read: OMG! Jesse Lee Soffer's New Show Creates a HUGE Problem for the FBI Universe!.

The Real-Life Larry Hall: A Serial Killer’s Elusive Confessions

A montage image of Larry Hall from Black Bird Image

Larry Hall’s conviction for kidnapping Jessica Roach (in 1995) was based on his initial confession. He would continuously give false accounts to authorities and confess to other events and moments. Those statements continuously changed, showing this remarkable and frustrating personality which made even obtaining information completely difficult to do!

His twin Gary’s role is also exactly what was shown! Gary, originally defensive, ended up assisting the FBI by working on his brother. The entire show portrays all that correctly–making those aspects surprisingly close to reality. And this incredibly important partnership allowed a truly terrifying, very effective method which made a crucial and surprisingly effective approach possible in obtaining necessary and incredibly difficult-to-find confessions. It’s one of the greatest, wildest parts of this remarkable tale; almost something only made for television itself!

Also Read: Dexter: Is it Worth Watching? Rotten Tomatoes Says Yes! (But there is a catch).

Jimmy Keene’s Deal with the Devil: A High-Stakes Gamble for Freedom

A collage of Ray Liotta, Taron Egerton, and Paul Walter Hauser in Black Bird Image

Jimmy Keene was initially a successful football star who’s life went way off track after that ’90s drug bust in Operation Snowplow and convicted on drug trafficking. The FBI's deal was crazy: work in prison with Larry; help authorities gain vital information from this alleged serial killer. Get this man's confession and you get your own freedom, otherwise you would face another longer time behind bars; which highlights the importance of the choices Jimmy faces during that critical juncture! The choice? A high-stakes risk!

Black Bird’s incredibly effective storyline was adapted from Jimmy’s experience; those months involved to build Larry’s trust! And despite ultimately not obtaining more evidence, Larry confessed (and retracted) providing evidence crucial for the legal proceedings to successfully indict Hall with an extremely important statement and moments later! His attempt to obtain additional information regarding the location of potential murder victims almost succeeded, generating other crucial details used later.

Also Read: FBI: International Season 4 - Everything We Know So Far

Larry Hall’s Conviction and Unanswered Questions

Taron Egerton as Jimmy Keene in prison in Black Bird Image

Larry Hall was convicted and given life without parole! He never got a murder conviction— only kidnapping. His actual life sentence came only because that act had resulted in murder, creating this complex layer where ambiguity remains, although the actual sentence delivered was quite appropriately strict. The real enigma and tragedy surrounding this is quite apparent.

To this day—we don’t know how many victims Larry Hall has! The FBI estimates up to 40 young women – showing this massive shadow that hasn't ever been cleared completely even after obtaining that incredibly important information!

Also Read: Firecracker Is The Most Unpredictable Character In The Boys Season 4

Jimmy Keene’s Time in Prison and Life After

Split image of Larry and Jimmy from Black Bird. Image

Jimmy Keene faced significant personal difficulties in real life that also appeared on-screen, even incorporating these issues into a well-developed plot device. While Black Bird doesn't mention his 17-month stay exactly, he ended up serving only a very brief time of this actual longer sentence before obtaining his freedom, a true example and reflection that justice operates even within highly controlled settings and when obtaining seemingly impossible situations in this remarkable story!

His father’s death remains sadly intact: the father-son relationship; one highlighted prominently and consistently throughout Black Bird’s short but memorable runtime. And Jimmy's role in writing that compelling memoir; later used as the backbone for Black Bird's creative and critically lauded script; became an incredible success for all people involved. His collaboration made all this into something so much bigger and so much more compelling, far beyond what many people were anticipating.

Black Bird's Omissions: The Details Left Untold

Larry Hall sitting in court in a scene from Black Bird. Image

The show’s accuracy is impressive, it left a lot out of the complete and factual account of the events of Black Bird; especially surrounding Larry Hall. Many things could've been explored regarding Larry's early life—acts of vandalism and possible involvement with other criminal behaviors were all left behind because, unlike his adult actions that caused damage to the lives of others, these don't necessarily convey what is considered an important aspect to his specific development as a violent and dangerous criminal!

These decisions helped maintain a closer adherence to the factual account; emphasizing how dangerous and capable Larry actually was: not the petty criminal that could potentially be built upon in the exploration of a more troubled early history but as that highly effective and immensely skilled and incredibly dangerous serial killer that he is known as! It remains a great testament of creative excellence.

Paul Walter Hauser’s Immersive Performance: A Devastating Experience

Black bird taron egerton james keene Image

Paul Walter Hauser did great in his portrayal; which required incredible depths of engagement with his own persona. This made his acting role remarkably compelling. He prepared in numerous ways to embody Larry Hall. Yet, portraying this darkness clearly took a toll (Hauser even got sober during filming); demonstrating this highly impressive level of devotion from the actor, highlighting just how significant these roles might actually be.

Dennis Lehane’s Vision: A True Crime Story with a Feminist Perspective

Split image from El Marginal and Mindhunter. Image

Dennis Lehane's insightful perspectives and critical take made the entire production what it is; it emphasizes the dark core and really highlights this story as an opportunity to explore this theme. He didn’t want the narrative to show a bunch of violence but a vehicle exploring femicide – using that true story as a way to highlight this incredibly relevant social issue. A unique goal; turning a darkly intense subject into an examination around those kinds of larger social issues.

Conclusion: Black Bird’s Powerfully Honest Story Telling

Paul Walter Hauser as Larry Hall in Black Bird Image

Black Bird successfully brought that true story to life; delivering a superb miniseries and that remarkably effective narrative design choice for emphasizing specific elements! Leaving minor points out–especially Larry’s earlier life— allowed it to remain focused on those extremely key relationships and moments. It brilliantly explores both darkness and the complexity of the justice system and made viewers confront issues regarding addiction, the dangers behind a serial killer, along with creating those highly effective and intensely difficult moments experienced throughout those characters. It leaves behind an intensely gripping and unforgettable story– for many reasons.