Billy Maximoff's Return in Agatha: Coven of Chaos: Theories & Explanations

Fans of Marvel's Scarlet Witch ( Wanda Maximoff) were left with some major questions after the WandaVision series ended. While her children, Billy and Tommy Maximoff, vanished after she released Westview from her hex, the latest series, Agatha: Coven of Chaos, brought a big surprise for those who loved her twins!

The Maximoff Twins and WandaVision

The Maximoff twins were first introduced in WandaVision (2021). This was a story showing Wanda's grief and the ability to create a fantasy world using her "chaos magic." She managed to do so by creating the town of Westview where she created a fictional world based around classic sitcoms!

In this exciting storyline, Wanda created Billy and Tommy.

Billy showed Wanda's magical abilities.
Tommy had the super speed abilities like his uncle Pietro Maximoff.

When Agatha Harkness broke the Hex, the twins vanished, leaving fans heartbroken! This became a cliffhanger that left lots of room for interpretation.

Also Read: WandaVision: The Impact of Wanda's Spell on Westview and the MCU

Agatha All Along and Billy's Return

Teen In Agatha With Brooms and Ouija Board Custom MCU Agatha Image Image

The mystery continued! In Agatha: Coven of Chaos, we got an unexpected twist as it was revealed that Joe Locke's character, "Teen," is actually Billy Maximoff! This was a shocking event as it confirmed many theories that had fans discussing and predicting.

Even with the confirmation that this was in fact, Billy, the question still remains how is he here? Billy from WandaVision was never really real! The most exciting theory suggests that Billy's current existence is from another universe. This comes after the events that unfolded in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness (2022), a film where Wanda journeyed to multiple universes in an attempt to reunite with her twins!

Also Read: Agatha All Along and WandaVision: The Mystery of the Teen

Billy's Identity in Agatha All Along

Tommy Maximoff in his speed costume in WandaVision Image

This reveal from Agatha: Coven of Chaos has some interesting implications!

The hex was broken which makes a reunion with his brother and Wanda almost impossible!
This means the existence of Billy requires some major plot changes! Maybe some alternate universes, or reviving his story somehow before the death of Wanda could add more complexity to the overall narrative! But for many, the coolest and most well-received explanation comes from the Marvel Comics. This was even shown in some cool scenes of the show, including a special charm or amulet that would not allow Billy to talk about who he was.
It's quite clever because many have always believed the characters have similar abilities like what you'd see in the comics
Another thing to consider was when Teen says that something huge happened to him around 13. That lines up perfectly as WandaVision occurs around this point. That really could push viewers into speculating whether he's from the multiverse or even possibly from a different world or some kind of reimagining!

Also Read: Agatha Harkness: Unmasking the Powerful Witch Beyond 'WandaVision'

Tommy Shepherd's Absence

Wiccan and Speed using their powers in Marvel Comics Image

The show may have answered a huge question, bringing Billy back. However, there is still another to answer- Tommy. While Agatha: Coven of Chaos was a fantastic, and pretty fun story arc, it still left audiences with major questions about Tommy! Even those fans with great insight about the lore will find there are gaps about Tommy. We can turn to Marvel comics. To give this theory some credibility!

Also Read: Agatha Harkness: Everything You Need to Know About the 'WandaVision' Witch

Marvel Comics and Reincarnation

Agatha All Along 2024 TV Show Poster Image

There are several key elements that stand out when explaining how both twins make their way back into the main timeline! A theory suggests they were "reincarnated" souls. So when Wanda used magic, and made the Maximoff twins in WandaVision. These new incarnations weren't just illusions!

This theory in Marvel comics makes Billy Kaplan and Tommy Shepherd to be the real deal after these lost souls managed to escape from Mephisto and get reborn.

Billy finds that he has special magic powers and also has Teddy Altman, a hybrid Kree-Skrull character as a boyfriend. The fact that the Marvel Comics series included Teddy as a person, gave fans hope! Fans that have closely followed Agatha: Coven of Chaos noted that Billy did get a call from a contact marked as "Boyf." This made fans pretty excited and has given them hope.
In the Marvel Comics these two will appear together! It shows an eventual reunion as both make it into The Young Avengers.
While Billy got into a bit of a magic journey in New York, his twin gets his own story!
He creates an immense explosion using his super speed abilities in his town which is in New Jersey.
There will also be major moments such as "Young Avengers" and how they work to save him!

The Future of the Maximoff Twins

Captain America Brave New World Film Release Date Poster Image

As for Agatha: Coven of Chaos, what did it bring to Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU)? This could be more than just getting the twins back into this new arc. While the fate of Tommy might be a cliffhanger it still has lots of MCU potential!

The series seems to focus heavily on creating a "Young Avengers" and while fans have been wanting this series for ages! The groundwork really got underway with Agatha: Coven of Chaos, leaving us wanting to learn more about where Billy and Tommy are! And for sure, a huge question: how do Wanda and Agatha end up together once again? This really will bring viewers back for ages and makes the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) more exciting!