Movies News Talk

Midnight Mass vs. Salem's Lot: Why Netflix's Horror Triumphs

Midnight Mass: The Unofficial Salem's Lot Remake That's Better Than the Real Thing!

Mike Flanagan's Midnight Mass: A Spiritual Successor to Salem's Lot

Horror fans know Mike Flanagan. The guy's a master. Three years ago, he unleashed Midnight Mass on Netflix, an original story with an insane 87% Rotten Tomatoes score!  What’s really insane? It’s better than any Salem’s Lot adaptation— including the newly released one – and even more important is the timing: It dropped three years BEFORE that disastrous new movie! We are talking an original that really delivers the kinds of suspense, psychological impact and story telling done expertly. Even more impressive is how similar that original project manages to evoke that same feeling generated from those older Salem's Lot adaptations.  It totally nails that Stephen King vibe; becoming better than many of the official attempts at conveying similar themes. It demonstrates the immense capacity that original concepts and interpretations of a well-known story might bring to its fans.

Salem's Lot (Stephen King's 1975 novel) centers on writer Ben Mears returning to his spooky hometown (Jerusalem's Lot, Maine). Turns out, its inhabitants became vampires! That ancient vampire, Kurt Barlow, becomes that huge antagonist. That intense story's core elements get totally reimagined in Midnight Mass—a truly compelling and terrifying experience which stays faithful to those classic horror stories yet introduces some unique twists! 

Also Read: Salem's Lot: Stephen King's Vampire Movie Gets a Remake - First Reactions Are In!

Midnight Mass: A Familiar Story With a Creepy Twist

Bev holding a candle in Midnight Mass overtop image of Paul in his robes in Midnight Mass Image

Midnight Mass is original.  But those similarities to Salem's Lot are shocking! Like Salem's Lot, a returning character's arrival deeply impacts the storyline's central elements!  Riley Flynn (not a writer but a troubled ex-venture capitalist, still battling a horrific drunk driving incident), returning to a deeply religious, almost isolated island community (Crockett Island).  Attendance at church is plummeting— then this enigmatic priest, Father Paul Hill arrives; he rekindles everyone's faith— through incredible seeming miracles— this becomes a narrative keystone, influencing nearly all those later narrative developments and actions made by different key players!

It does so through shocking revelations and plot twists which lead to later narrative and major developments! That mysterious, almost unbelievable miracle-making Father Paul brings back something more from his trip. This amazing detail is what totally transforms everyone involved into a new phase of reality, something almost entirely unseen and unpredictable for most characters; further highlighting why that core theme regarding isolation plays such an important role in the narrative structure. He carries an incredibly profound and powerful dark secret– this terrifying secret becomes that supernatural vampire antagonist who changes things!

Also Read: Salem's Lot Rotten Tomatoes Score: Is the New Adaptation Any Good?

Midnight Mass vs. the 2024 Salem's Lot: A Tale of Two Adaptations

Kate Siegel as Erin Greene in Netflix Midnight Mass Image

Midnight Mass is far from a straight Salem's Lot adaptation, though that core influence shows heavily throughout! Its intense and immersive nature— those scary themes revolving around faith and horror, create many powerful story moments; and compared to that rather disappointing 2024 film, it is clearly superior— making it easily that best take on this novel since the 1979 miniseries! It also highlights a profound theme regarding forgiveness – deeply examined and central throughout the storytelling! Father Paul’s dark act serves as that incredibly necessary context: he brings this monstrous being to the island to self-punish and this extremely powerful reasoning shapes this particular drama!

Midnight Mass masterfully weaves that complex interplay between faith, horror, and guilt!  That clever use of religious themes; and its amazing symbolism, coupled with intense, shocking moments— perfectly conveys the horror; something that many Stephen King adaptations sometimes completely miss or fumble! The entire theme; that focus upon forgiveness which permeates throughout the story, is what drives it and makes it so powerful! And that clever integration perfectly showcases this particular director’s understanding and his capability of integrating some important societal observations with creative plot twists which elevates everything involved!

Also Read: Stephen King's 'Salem's Lot' Remake: A New Chapter in Horror

Conclusion: A Must-Watch Horror Experience

 Image

If you loved Salem's Lot, or really like horror and those intense narratives concerning faith and fear and redemption and loss; give Midnight Mass a watch; this title showcases just how great an original production might be given sufficient effort and excellent creativity. It’s so far beyond the typical Stephen King adaptation— its amazing emotional power is incredible— making it far superior to even those earlier productions based on similar plots, delivering an incredibly gripping viewing experience and reminding viewers that a true horror production can go beyond a well-known trope!  This makes it a true triumph! And the ending will leave many audiences eager to re-experience the story entirely again!

Related Articles