Movies News Talk

Wuthering Heights: Controversy Surrounds Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi Casting

Who Are Margot Robbie And Jacob Elordi?

The decision to cast Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi - those two famous and well-known actors - has set off a series of controversial debates about those decisions which were made by director Emerald Fennell. As the two stars of the film: Wuthering Heights - a classic adaptation of the novel that is often cited as one of the most enduring - and powerful tragedies in literature, it brings up a range of important topics such as those questions of representation - and the complex and often complicated relationship between an author’s original vision – and how those characters have been depicted on screen.

Margot Robbie, has starred in those movies which are often cited for their memorable and iconic performances. She’s been a fixture in popular Hollywood productions, often landing some of the most recognizable roles such as: I, Tonya a biographical film – which showcases how she played the title role of Tonya Harding and her infamous career. This, of course, would bring her to greater prominence - and to other leading roles including those parts she would play in: The Suicide Squad, a major superhero film involving a DC Comic property and, one of the characters in The Wolf of Wall Street, which gives her a range of characters, that will be seen - on screen, including those roles that she'll later take in the upcoming productions including her parts as those key characters: Barbie a production that was highly anticipated and one of the most popular - those films that are being released in 2023. As fans will notice that those events that surround those movies often lead to more interest and anticipation for those productions, where Jacob Elordi’s casting in this role: as Heathcliff, gives him an opportunity to break free from some of his previous characters, and his previous appearances in films such as The Kissing Booth a young adult rom-com series, and more recently the film Euphoria. It is this type of character that often will bring an actor to greater prominence.

Who Is Emily Brontë?

Edward's image superimposed on Wuthering Heights. Image

Emily Brontë - an essential, important, figure, that has left a legacy in the world of literature - an author, known for her talents, and her contributions to one of the most iconic, popular and well-known genres of English Literature - a genre: known as Gothic Literature, with that stark - and sometimes gruesome - depiction of those characters - and the desolate landscapes.

Her contribution to this genre, has come in the form of her only published novel, that was released in 1847. Wuthering Heights the book that has captured the hearts of millions of readers and those viewers who have witnessed its power and its influence in the cinematic adaptation of her book, it shows just how she became an important, major and compelling writer, especially within those periods: a period of British Literature. Wuthering Heights, an example of just how influential: Emily Brontë’s - writing has become and how the characters she created - those characters who have captured the imaginations - and also the hearts of readers and, those who have come to see those characters on the screen.

Is There A Racial Representation Problem in The Wuthering Heights Movie?

Jacob Elordi smiles as he looks over his shoulder, wearing a blue shirt. Image

It seems that the movie adaptation of Wuthering Heights will be a film which causes a great deal of Controversy for the filmmakers, those who are involved and for the audiences - who will see those productions: the actors and the decisions that are made.

There are questions about Heathcliff’s racial identity - one of the major issues. While he is not explicitly defined as having any particular race or background in the text – the novel does have a very detailed depiction - which describes Heathcliff - and how that individual has a look that is distinctly different from the main white - Anglo - English characters in the book.

Will Margot Robbie And Jacob Elordi Capture Those Classic Characters - From Wuthering Heights ?

Wuthering Heights (1939) - Poster Image

Heathcliff an iconic figure, in a popular book that has become, quite a controversy as those fans - of the novel and of the movie adaptations that have been released, wondering what choices will be made in this production and whether Margot Robbie will capture: that iconic - and sometimes - rather tragic - portrayal of Cathy.

With the decision to cast Jacob Elordi in this role, as the main lead - as Heathcliff - many will wonder if those key elements will be reflected. In this book, there is a dark, brooding, personality. He is one who faces those hardships that come from a tragic and tumultuous love story.

Who Has Played Cathy And Heathcliff In Previous Adaptations of Wuthering Heights ?

Logo-Prime Video.jpg.png Image

There are those famous movie adaptations, those that have tried to bring this story - of Heathcliff and Cathy - to life for audiences. With several Adaptations that have been released: it’s a tale, and a history that will be explored. The story of Wuthering Heights , it will be seen how the film makers choose those actors - and their choices as they move forward with their respective production of the book.

The choices have varied over the years as fans have seen a range of performances - those that are quite remarkable. One of the first and perhaps most recognizable film adaptations that took place was in the 1930’s with Wuthering Heights a film which was starring Laurence Olivier. Many audiences - will notice the major changes and those dramatic transformations: It's how that movie - and that film version - changed that storyline and how the characters - would be presented on screen. It would take some time - before there would be more faithful adaptations and that is why those choices were often controversial. One such film, was that adaptation from the 1970’s that would have the lead actors - who would take on those iconic roles.

Is The Controversy Over Wuthering Heights Going to Damage the Movie Production?

Peacock Logo Image

There are some those movies, those films, and television series that will gain more controversy - after a certain point in the production - sometimes even before it begins. This would include Wuthering Heights.

While it is difficult to say for certain, whether this Backlash is going to harm those key elements: a film’s box office performance, the director's future success or whether this will be something which is ignored - the decision to choose those particular actors to fill the role: Heathcliff - and, Cathy. Those fans who have followed this tale and have seen those different interpretations of this popular story.

Related Articles