Rotten Tomatoes: When Critics and Audiences Disagree on Movies

How Can You Tell Which Movies To Watch Based on Critic Reviews?

In the film world, one of the most widely cited websites, rotten tomatoes, helps to provide audiences and film fans with an assortment of insights regarding a movie’s reception. For each movie that's added to its database - it features both a critic score (which represents what the critics think of a movie) and a audience score - which represents those viewers’ perspectives. While audiences may assume there's consistency, often times this is not true as viewers discover just how differently those groups evaluate films. In many cases, there may be a significant discrepancy. It's common to discover how one group may not like what the other loves.

It's a reminder that those interested in watching a new film or selecting from a long list of movie recommendations , have a chance to discover those Movies where audiences and critics agree - and others where their feelings diverge. Some movies that audiences love but critics hate are often based on an ability to offer enjoyment that’s light, breezy and entertaining but lack those same elements of a deep narrative. This is a prime example of how rotten tomatoes audience score vs critic score could differ drastically.

Why Do Critics and Audiences Have Differing Opinions on Movies?

King-Kong-Naomi-Watts-Adrien-Brody-Sausage-Party-The-Last-Jedi-Rey-Daisy-Ridley Image

The difference in opinion between critics and audiences often comes down to perspective - in addition to the different sets of criteria for evaluation. When watching films critics are often expected to look at a film's technical components such as whether the film features a unique concept, an impressive production value, an original script, or if it features strong characters with complex storylines that capture a unique or interesting angle.

In comparison, the average viewer often seeks enjoyment from the overall viewing experience. If the story features a thrilling or a fun narrative and compelling performances, viewers are not as concerned with how technical elements like the quality of the script or those complex storylines that critics often pay attention to.

What is a Mismatched Reception on Rotten Tomatoes?

Michelle Yeoh and Ziyi Zhang in the garden in Memoirs Of A Geisha. Image

It’s quite common to see a difference in critic score and audience score, but there are often a significant number of Movies that are divisive among critics and audiences as a result - often because their scores differ so greatly, particularly if audience score is remarkably higher. One of the best ways to see this is on rotten tomatoes.

Those who watch Rotten Tomatoes audience score vs critic score know there is often a difference. The website showcases both sets of opinions: one from critics, who have experience analyzing films with their unique standards, and audiences. Their evaluations often offer more insight into how those unpopular movies and those popular movies receive both favorable and unfavorable responses from audiences who enjoy them - showcasing how audiences may love films critics might hate. Some movies with different reception from critics and audiences (critics vs audiences on movies) tend to emphasize how those movies are more of a lighthearted viewing experience. While they may lack the same amount of complexity they are designed to make viewers happy, relax and offer some light entertainment. It's a stark difference to movies with a wide gap in critic and audience ratings.

How Does Rotten Tomatoes Help Moviegoers Find Films to Watch?

Channing Tatum Jenna Dewan Step Up Image

While moviegoers might use the critic score (that appears in Rotten Tomatoes - which has the ability to display an impressive number of film reviews) and audience score. The platform’s ratings may provide audiences with guidance to see a selection of movies. Those watching movie recommendations will find films where those rotten tomatoes audience score vs critic score scores align.

For example, there is a wide variety of movies with high audience scores that show just how movies with a lower critic score may appeal to movie fans. It’s the opposite for those who seek films that critics have rated highly (those movies with low critic score) but audiences might disagree with those opinions. The main element is a way to better explore how to find good movies based on audience score.

Why Might Movies Receive Different Reactions?

Norman Reedus and Sean Patrick Flanery pointing guns in The Boondock Saints (1999). Image

It’s common to find those films with different reviews from critics and audiences but it’s important to realize that these differences arise from differing standards, opinions, expectations and also the role that the audience is taking. Those watching movies, can often find it very entertaining, however, critics might feel as if a film fails to reach those goals that would be seen as "artfully done."

It’s a constant battle of perspectives that may leave audiences wondering about what’s "bad" and what’s "good." However, critics do have a long history of setting a high standard when it comes to analyzing movies but they still are subjective. As it is said “it takes all types." It’s worth understanding how to understand audience and critic movie ratings and that the opinions that are made about films are often designed to help film lovers find an even better and more personal, enjoyable film watching experience.

What Are Some Popular Movies That Received a Mixed Response?

Brian Dennehy in Tommy Boy with Chris Farley Image

In a long history of popular movies - one will find that there are some critically-acclaimed movies with low audience scores. However, that is often not as frequent as audience-pleasing movies with poor critical reception.

When watching these movies, it's a prime example of how critics vs audiences (which could also be viewed as those who are more discerning, have strong standards in those movie reviews and those who might look at those same movies differently, possibly due to their ability to entertain, have a simple and pleasant storyline, and some engaging humor - in contrast to those movies that critics are seeking which include those more complex stories with an abundance of characters and a highly complicated narrative arc) can differ, ultimately resulting in those movies that audiences loved but critics hated.